Steven TÖTÖSY
de ZEPETNEK
From Comparative Literature Today Toward Comparative
Cultural Studies
Abstract: Steven Tötösy de Zepetnek proposes in his article,
"From Comparative Literature Today Toward Comparative Cultural Studies," a theoretical
approximation of already established and current aspects of the disciplines
of comparative literature and cultural studies. His comparative cultural studies
is conceived as an approach -- to be developed eventually to a full-fledged
framework -- containing at this point three areas of theoretical content: 1)
To study literature (text and/or literary system) with and in the context of
culture and the discipline of cultural studies; 2) In cultural studies itself
to study literature with borrowed elements (theories and methods) from comparative
literature; and 3) To study culture and its composite parts and aspects in the
mode of the proposed "comparative cultural studies" approach instead of the
currently reigning single-language approach dealing with a topic with regard
to its nature and problematics in one culture only. At the same time, comparative
cultural studies would implicitly and explicitly disrupt the established hierarchy
of cultural products and production similarly to the disruption cultural studies
itself has performed. The suggestion is to prularize and paralellize the study
of culture without hierarchization. The article contains brief descriptions
of recent volumes in comparative literature across the globe and closes with
a ten-point draft proposal of how to do comparative cultural studies.
Johannes F. WELFING
Nietzsche and the Knowledge of the Child at Play:
On the Question of Metaphysics
Abstract: In his paper, "Nietzsche and the Knowledge of the Child at
Play: On the Question of Metaphysics," Johannes Welfing raises the question
of a Nietzschean metaphysical presence (did Nietzsche define the essence of
life and of being and thus also implicitly establish an imperative about the
way in which one should lead one's life, or did he refrain from all definition,
truth, system or law whatsoever?). The controversy continues: while for some
critics Nietzsche's philosophy is animated by a desire for truth, others emphasize
the novelty of a philosophical project that questions the very premises on which
it is based. In particular, the author attempts to establish, by referring
to a specific excerpt from the Nietzsche text, that the paradigm of the Nietzschean
child at play on the "beach of life" -- argument of an important, contemporary
brand of Nietzsche interpretation that situates Nietzsche beyond the metaphysical
tradition -- cannot be said to be truly based on the Nietzsche text. While focusing
on both Alan Schrift's and Mihailo Djuric's argument that Nietzsche attempted
to escape the metaphysical tradition by emphasizing the knowledge of the child
at play, Welfing argues that for Nietzsche -- if knowledge is to secure the
escape from the belief in metaphysical essence on the level of practical life
-- this knowledge is generated by the body rather than by the rational
mind.
William H. THORNTON
A Postmodern Solzhenitsyn?
Abstract: William H. Thornton undertakes in his article, "A Postmodern
Solzhenitsyn?," to bring Solzhenitsyn in from the cold, critically speaking,
by closing the gap between him and his many postmodern detractors. That gap
has been premised on the rough equivalence of poststructuralism and postmodernism.
The postmodern realism advanced in this study challenges not only Solzhenitsyn's
critics but his own stated aversion to postmodernism.Operating on both a microhistorical
and macrohistorical plane, Solzhenitsyn's literary historiography testifies
to the awesome scope of the gulag while never losing sight of its human factor.The
double vision of Solzhenitsyn's proto-postmodern referentiality, a simultaneous
centering and decentering, is matched by his determination to keep the past
as a creative force within the present and future. Here poststructural, anti-realist
post-modernism becomes his adversary; for just as it attempts to comprehend
the local in pristine isolation, never connecting the dots, so too it isolates
the past. Solzhenitsyn accuses (anti-realist) postmodernism of recycling many
of the same avant-garde tools of forgetfulness that were used ever so effectively
early in the twentieth century to dismantle existing cultural values, and indeed
the very category of the cultural as a setting for local meaning.
Jean WILSON
Identity Politics in Atwood, Kogawa, and Wolf
Abstract: Jean Wilson's article, "Identity Politics in Atwood, Kogawa,
and Wolf," is a comparative study of three texts published in the early 1980s:
Atwood's "Significant Moments in the Life of My Mother," Kogawa's Obasan,
and Wolf's Cassandra. Identity politics figure prominently in all three
literary works, whose common poetic project is one of demythologization and
of enabling at the same time the emergence of a new, liberating articulation,
a language perhaps "never heard before." These writings interrogate the construction
of identities in a patriarchal culture and contribute to a more complex understanding
of identity formation. All three works, albeit in different ways, challenge
readers to consider identity interrogatively and to explore in new voices what
it means to say "we," to say "they," to say "you," to say "I."
Book Review Articles
Manuel YANG
Familial Autobiography and the World:
A Review Article of Work by Kenzaburo
Thomas PAVEL
A Review of Work by Souiller and Troubetzkoy
Ernst GRABOVSZKI
New Ways in Comparative Literature:
A Review Article of New Work by Tötösy,
Dimic, and Sywenky, and Tötösy